Nest Audio

A Google Home replacement built to be 75% louder and have 50% stronger bass than its predecessor, the Nest Audio is also the best Google Assistant speaker available today thanks to a speedy voice processing chip. Despite not being the most powerful speaker, it offers excellent dynamic range and crystal clear sound.

Nest Audio

New upgrades, better price

Three highly receptive microphones

Audio clarity and dynamic range

Multiple colors and blended-in buttons

Best for Google Assistant commands

More affordable

No AirPlay or Alexa

Narrow soundstage

Sonos One

Despite launching in 2017, the Sonos One has mostly kept pace, or even stayed ahead of new smart speakers on the market, particularly in sound quality. The S2 app supports a thorough list of music libraries, since you cannot stream them on the One using Bluetooth. If you want to control devices with Alexa and Google Assistant at once, or pair with other Sonos tech, this is a good option.

Sonos One

Older tech, better audio

Integrated Alexa and Google Assistant

AirPlay 2 support for iOS users

Ethernet port

Room-filling sound

Pairs with other Sonos cams

No Bluetooth support

Expensive

Microphone quality is mediocre

Breaking down the Nest Audio vs Sonos One comes down first and foremost to smarts versus audio quality. Sonos has made incremental upgrades to its premium speaker since it launched in 2017, but the more affordable Nest Audio brings vastly improved 2020 tech to the fray, and makes an admirable effort to live up to the beautiful audio quality of the Sonos One. Is Sonos One still the best smart speaker in 2020? We'll give you our verdict below.

Nest Audio vs Sonos One: Spec showdown

We've collected all of the key information you need to know about the Nest Audio vs. Sonos One features — or, at least, the information that was available. Unlike most speaker manufacturers, Sonos isn't completely upfront about the tech that goes into its speakers. We know that the Sonos One 2nd Gen received a new processor and upgraded memory, but Sonos doesn't actually say what the old or new components were, or how significant the change was. Nor do we know how large its speaker drivers are, or the device's wattage.

Still, the data we could find, combined with our reviews of both products, should help you get a clear sense of how they compare to one another.

With its cylindrical frame, flat button-filled top and small LED indicator that shines when the mic is listening, the Sonos One has a very "traditional" body. It lacks the 3.5mm port for connecting to another speaker, but does sport an ethernet port that will help it keep a consistent internet connection. By contrast, the Nest Audio has a more exciting, unusual design. You can buy it in colors besides black and white, it has a more uniform build without the flat plastic top, and has four clearly visible, front-facing LED indicators for when the microphone is listening to you.

The Nest Audio works with more Wi-Fi standards, streams content from mobile devices via Bluetooth and (we believe) has a faster processor, which will allow it to respond to voice commands or perform actions more quickly. You can control it with native Google Assistant commands designed specifically by Google for the speaker, picked up by the speaker's hypersensitive mic array.

Sonos plays nicer with more tech ecosystems, supporting Alexa, Google Assistant and AirPlay all at once. Theoretically, it's like you're buying a Sonos Three-in-One, since you would need an Echo, Nest Audio and a third Apple-compliant speaker just to get the same compatibility. Unfortunately, it doesn't support Bluetooth, but the Sonos S2 app gives you access to all of the music streaming platforms that you would normally need Bluetooth to access.

We don't know the exact sizes of the Sonos One's tweeter and woofer, making it difficult to compare them against the Nest Audio's. Yet we know that the Sonos One is wider, longer and heavier (though a bit shorter), which suggests its speakers may be a bit larger. Plus, Sonos uses digital amplifiers meant to boost the speaker's volume capacity.

Nest Audio vs Sonos One: Is better sound worth twice the cost?

In our Nest Audio review, we specificially weighed the Nest Audio versus the Sonos one in audio performance. Our reviewer had this to say:

"There's an airiness to music that comes out of the Sonos One that feels more compressed and isolated on the Nest Audio, but they both reproduce vocals and instruments wonderfully. The Sonos One is more precise and has a cleaner, more enjoyable low-end, but not by much".

The Nest Audio's uncompressed sound is actually by design, according to the official Google announcement). The engineers decided to "minimize the use of compressors to preserve dynamic range", meaning quiet or loud moments retain their audible contrast from one another even if the volume is low or turned up to 11.

Our Nest reviewer praised the Audio's performance, saying that "the low-end is clean and inviting, vocals come through beautifully, and there's no sharpness or sibilance at the high-end." While it doesn't match up with the Sonos One in quality, it comes close at a lower price. In fact, you could buy two Nest Audios for the price of one Sonos One, then pair them together for stereo sound.

On the other hand, the Nest Audio's sound is highly directional by design. Placed on the right shelf, it can deliver music to a sweet spot right to where you typically sit in the living room. But it won't fill a room like the Sonos One will, thanks to its wider soundstage and better drivers.

Nest Audio vs Sonos One: Smart speaker IQ test

Google Assistant-enabled smart speakers all generally work with the same library of commands. In fact, Google just recently added new commands to help you navigate third-party apps using simple "Hey Google" phrases on phones or smart displays.

Even though Sonos took over a year to add Google Assistant to the Sonos One, it did eventually manage it. Now, both speakers have access to the same assistant tech. Considering Sonos also grants users access to Alexa commands, one would assume that Sonos is the logical choice for a versatile smart speaker.

In practice, you must look carefully at their microphone tech. Sonos placed six mics into its One speaker, but our Sonos One reviewer wasn't impressed, claiming that all of his Echo smart speakers understood his Alexa commands better than the Sonos One. That was three years ago, before the Audio even existed, but unfortunately for Sonos nothing has changed: when we tested the Nest Audio against the Sonos One, the Nest Audio could discern words more easily.

You'll also get faster Google Assistant answers, thanks to the speedy processing chip and machine learning technology that Google shoved into the device. Our reviewer claimed that the Nest Audio carried the "most responsive Google Assistant has ever been on a speaker".

Keeping that in mind, you will likely prefer a speaker with one excellent voice assistant, than a speaker with multiple assistants that all have trouble deciphering what you want!

Nest Audio vs Sonos One: Which should you buy?

We lean towards recommending the Nest Audio, but there are several scenarios where buying the Sonos One makes sense. Frequent Apple users may prefer Sonos due to its AirPlay support, as Google has no plans to support Apple apps in the future. Or, if you have spotty wi-fi, Sonos' ethernet port is a good way to make sure your music streams don't constantly jitter or buffer.

If you own other Sonos devices, you'll want to stick with that ecosystem and link them all together for a multi-room setup. Particularly if you own a Sonos soundbar like the Arc, since you can use the One as a rear speaker and improve the soundbar's Dolby Atmos performance, while also letting it serve as an assistant.

Otherwise, we think the Nest Audio is the better choice. It has impressed us with its Google Assistant speeds, automatic EQ adjustments based on the type of content being played, automatic environmental tracking to determine if the room is loud and the volume needs to climb to compensate, and a more reasonable price.

Nest Audio

Best Google Assistant speaker
With improved volume, dynamic range, and bass, the Nest Audio sounds better than any Google speaker before it, and also listens more attentively to commands than ever before. With its fast Google Assistant response time and Bluetooth support, the Audio should be your first choice.

Sonos One

Excellent audio for its size
The Sonos One works with Alexa, Google Assistant and AirPlay 2, plus it pairs with other Sonos devices for stereo or even surround sound. Make sure not to buy the Sonos One SL, which ships without built-in microphones so you have no access to any of the smart assistants.